This post may contain affiliate links, which earn us commission. Learn more.
Comic book movies have given us some of the most thrilling cinematic experiences, from epic superhero sagas to heartfelt origin stories. But let’s be honest—for every Avengers: Endgame, there’s a catastrophic flop that leaves audiences wondering, “Why did anyone greenlight this?” Some comic book adaptations are so misguided, poorly executed, or downright baffling that it’s a wonder they ever got past the pitch stage. Whether it was due to poor casting, awful scripts, tone-deaf direction, or a complete misunderstanding of the source material, these cinematic misfires should never have seen the light of day.
Here are ten comic book movies that probably should’ve remained shelved:
1. Catwoman (2004)
Halle Berry’s turn as Catwoman is infamous for all the wrong reasons. Instead of sticking to the established lore of the Batman universe, the film reinvented the character with a convoluted origin story involving ancient Egyptian cat gods and a magical resurrection. Berry’s costume looked like something from a Halloween store clearance bin, and the CGI was so laughable that it pulled audiences out of the movie entirely. Despite Berry’s undeniable charisma, the dialogue, editing, and tone made the entire experience a cringe-fest. It’s no surprise she accepted her Razzie in person.
2. Fantastic Four (2015)
As a reboot of Marvel’s first family, this film had potential. A talented young cast including Miles Teller, Michael B. Jordan, and Kate Mara seemed like a great start. But the movie quickly became a case study in how behind-the-scenes turmoil can tank a film. From reports of director clashes to bizarre editing choices and a plot that abruptly shifts gears halfway through, Fantastic Four never found its footing. The final act felt rushed, the characters lacked depth, and Dr. Doom was criminally underused. It managed to be worse than the 2005 version—no small feat.
3. Batman & Robin (1997)
This neon-soaked fever dream nearly killed the Batman franchise for a decade. Director Joel Schumacher went full camp, loading the film with groan-worthy one-liners, toyetic gadgets, and enough day-glo lighting to make a rave jealous. George Clooney, while a decent Bruce Wayne, never felt like Batman, and his suit’s inexplicable nipples became an internet joke before memes were even a thing. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Mr. Freeze was all puns and no menace, and the film’s attempts at emotion felt forced and phony. It’s become a cult “so-bad-it’s-good” watch, but back then, it was a cinematic tragedy.
4. Elektra (2005)
After the lukewarm reception of Daredevil (2003), no one was clamoring for a spin-off. Still, we got Elektra—a moody, directionless solo outing for a character better suited as a supporting player. Jennifer Garner gave it her all, but the screenplay gave her very little to work with. The plot involved a mystical war between good and evil assassins, but it was all delivered in such a bland, lifeless way that even the action scenes felt slow. The movie missed an opportunity to explore Elektra’s darker, morally complex side and instead reduced her to a stoic, one-note protagonist.
5. Green Lantern (2011)
DC had high hopes for Green Lantern to kick off a shared cinematic universe. Unfortunately, the final product was an overstuffed mess. The film attempted to juggle cosmic politics, origin storytelling, and romance, but failed to excel in any of those areas. The visual effects looked more like a cutscene from a PS2 game than a big-budget blockbuster, and the decision to make the entire costume CGI backfired spectacularly. Ryan Reynolds has since joked about how bad it was—and honestly, he’s right. Not even the talented supporting cast could save this clunky green mess.
6. Howard the Duck (1986)
Long before the MCU became a box office juggernaut, George Lucas produced this oddball adaptation of Marvel’s snarky, cigar-smoking duck. The result was a tonal disaster that couldn’t decide if it was a kid’s movie, a satire, or something else entirely. The animatronic Howard looked creepy instead of charming, and the inclusion of a bizarre duck-human romance with Lea Thompson left many viewers more than a little disturbed. Add in awkward humor and messy storytelling, and you’ve got a film that’s legendary for all the wrong reasons.
7. Suicide Squad (2016)
When the first trailer dropped, it looked like DC might finally embrace a more stylized, gritty direction. Instead, Suicide Squad ended up being an incoherent mash-up of clashing tones, sloppy storytelling, and underdeveloped characters. Jared Leto’s Joker was divisive at best and cringeworthy at worst. The film relied heavily on needle-drop pop songs to set the mood, often jumping from scene to scene like a music video edited in a rush. The real tragedy? With its cast and concept, this movie had the potential to be something truly unique.
8. Steel (1997)
Take a beloved Superman spin-off character, cast NBA legend Shaquille O’Neal, and remove any trace of his connection to Superman. What could possibly go wrong? Everything. Steel was a low-budget affair that played more like a made-for-TV movie than a theatrical release. Shaq, charismatic though he may be, wasn’t ready to carry a film, especially one that asked him to play a weapons engineer-turned-vigilante. Between wooden acting, laughable action scenes, and a costume that looked like spray-painted cardboard, Steel was doomed to rust.
9. Jonah Hex (2010)
Mixing supernatural elements with a gritty Western could have worked—but Jonah Hex fumbled the execution. Josh Brolin broods his way through a muddy script filled with cliches, and Megan Fox’s character exists solely to look attractive. The film tries to juggle a revenge plot, mystical resurrection powers, and a villain played by John Malkovich with scenery-chewing glee, but none of it gels. At a brisk 81 minutes, it’s almost like the studio gave up and hit “export” on the first cut they had.
10. Spawn (1997)
Fans were excited to see Todd McFarlane’s dark, brooding antihero come to life. Unfortunately, Spawn suffered from a murky script, a wildly inconsistent tone, and visual effects that aged faster than milk. Michael Jai White did his best under heavy makeup and armor, but the film didn’t give him much to work with. Meanwhile, John Leguizamo’s clownish villain, though the only true redeeming quality of the film, veered into annoying rather than menacing. Spawn had the ingredients to be something revolutionary for its time—instead, it ended up as a cautionary tale about prioritizing flashy visuals over a solid story.
While comic book films can be spectacular when done right, these ten disasters serve as a cautionary tale for filmmakers everywhere. From misguided artistic choices to rushed production schedules and studio interference, these movies highlight just how easily superhero cinema can go off the rails. Here’s hoping future adaptations learn from these blunders rather than repeat them.
What did we miss? Do you agree with our list? Let us know in the comments!